- Dishonesty
- Scandals
- Link
- Media about:
(presence of circumstances indicating a probable violation by the pursuer of the Law of Ukraine "On Prevention of Corruption"):
Opacity of wealth
According to the declaration for 2014 year, there is no information about whether the judge or her family has the right of ownership or the right to use real estate in which one can live permanently. The legislation obliges to declare the real estate objects owned by the judge and her family members as private property or leased or under other right of use. Thus, the judge should declare the housing in which she lives (uses) on any grounds.
Making questionable decisions
As can be seen from the resolution of the High Council of Justice, judge Bortnytska issued two resolutions (in the cases No. 757/26252/13-k and No. 757/26253/13-k) on the application of a preventive measure in the form of detention to two activists of the rally "For European integration" in front of the House of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine at the address of Kyiv, str. Hrushevsky 12/2. As stated in Lustration list of Euromaidan, the mentioned resolutions concerned O. D. Matyash and V. S. Blagodarny. At the same time, O. D. Matyash is a disabled person of the 3rd group, received from the beatings of "Berkut" a closed cranial brain injury, concussion, numerous bruises of the soft tissues of the face and chest. Ten people's deputies appealed to the judge with petitions to take them on bail, but the judge rejected the petition.
Disciplinary sanctions and punishments:
Was brought to disciplinary responsibility The Supreme Council of Justice
Journalists found out, that the current deputy head of the Office of the President, Oleg Tatarov, was the supervisor of Bortnytska, who defended her thesis for the degree of candidate of legal sciences.
https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/802/2003#Text
https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1029-17#Text
https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/245/2011#Text
Vita Bortnytska is a criminal in a cloak and an enemy of Ukraine
Conclusion on non-compliance of the judge with the criteria of integrity and professional ethics
I wrote my dissertation at Tatarov: what is known about Judge Bortnytska
Matyas and Blagradnoy are locked up in the pre-trial detention center on November 27, 2013
A Kyiv judge suspected of corruption was ordered to be arrested and bailed
The court refused to suspend the head of "Information Court Systems" Zhivaev
How the court helped Rosenblatt, a figure in the amber case, to defend himself from NABU
Related cases
Sivoho's case
The case is against veterans of the "Azov" regiment Serhiy Tamarin, Yuriy Kaplyu and Oleksandr Demydov.
The case of Sheremet
The case against Andrii Antonenko, Yulia Kuzmenko, Yana Dugar ("Sheremet's case")